Ever asked ChatGPT the same question twice and got different answers? You’re not alone.
This isn’t a glitch or error – it’s a feature built into how these AI systems work. But this raises important questions for businesses and users who rely on these tools daily.
In this article, we’ll explore whether ChatGPT gives identical responses to everyone, what factors influence its answers, and how this impacts your work and decisions.
What Affects ChatGPT’s Responses?
ChatGPT doesn’t work from a database of pre-written answers. Instead, it generates text based on patterns it learned during training. This leads to natural variation in its responses. Several key factors determine what answer you’ll get:
Temperature Settings
Think of temperature as ChatGPT’s creativity dial:
- Low temperature (0-0.3): More predictable, focused answers
- Medium temperature (0.4-0.7): Balanced between creativity and focus
- High temperature (0.8-1.0): More creative, varied responses
A business writing legal documents might set the temperature near zero for consistency, while a writer looking for creative ideas might crank it up to 0.8 or higher.
How to adjust the temperature in ChatGPT:
Unfortunately the temperature can only be changed when using the OpenAI API, rather than through the web-based interface. It can be adjusted using the following code:
{
"model": "gpt-4o",
"messages": [{"role": "user", "content": "Explain quantum mechanics simply."}],
"temperature": 0.7
}Remember that temperature changes only affect new messages – not previous responses.
System Prompts and Instructions
OpenAI and other providers set base instructions that guide how the AI responds to all users. These “system prompts” shape the AI’s behavior, tone, and limitations.
Different ChatGPT versions (free vs. Plus) and custom GPTs have different base instructions. This means the same question can get different answers depending on which version you’re using.
How to use system prompts effectively:
- In ChatGPT web interface:
- Create a custom GPT (requires Plus subscription)
- Click “Create a GPT” from the main menu
- Use the “Configure” tab to set system instructions
- Be specific about tone, style, and formatting requirements
- Test your GPT with various inputs to refine your instructions
In the API:
{
"model": "gpt-4",
"messages": [
{"role": "system", "content": "You are a legal assistant who provides concise, accurate information with citations to relevant laws."},
{"role": "user", "content": "What are the requirements for forming an LLC?"}
]
}- For regular ChatGPT chats:
- Begin your conversation with clear instructions
- Example: “In this conversation, please answer all questions in bullet point format and focus only on scientific facts.”
- Pin important instructions using the pin feature
- Remind the AI of key instructions in complex conversations
Remember that custom GPTs maintain your system instructions across all user interactions, while regular chats require setting your expectations in each new conversation.
Model Versions
The gap between GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 is significant:
- GPT-3.5: Faster, less nuanced, trained on older data
- GPT-4: More capable, better at following instructions, newer knowledge
This creates a natural split – two users asking the same question will get different answers if they’re using different models.
How to select different models:
- In the ChatGPT web interface: Look for the model selector dropdown menu in the bottom-left corner of your screen. Free users can access GPT-3.5, while Plus subscribers can choose between GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and other available models.
- In the API: Specify the model in your request by changing the “model” parameter (e.g., “gpt-3.5-turbo” or “gpt-4”).
Your Phrasing Matters
Tiny changes in how you ask can lead to dramatically different responses. Adding “write this for a 10-year-old” or “I need a detailed technical explanation” completely changes the output.
For example:
- “Tell me about Mars” vs. “What are the key facts about Mars?”
- “How do I bake bread?” vs. “What’s the easiest way to bake bread for beginners?”
These subtle differences trigger different patterns in the AI’s training.
Previous Messages in Your Chat
ChatGPT considers your conversation history when responding. This means:
- If you’ve been discussing marketing, it might frame answers through that lens
- If you corrected it earlier, it tries to avoid making the same mistake
- If you’ve established a casual tone, it continues with that style
Two users asking identical questions mid-conversation will likely get different answers based on their unique chat histories.
Our Test: Same Questions, Different Users
We conducted a simple experiment to see how consistent ChatGPT really is. We asked identical questions across different scenarios:
- 5 different user accounts
- Both free GPT-3.5 and paid GPT-4
- At different times of day
- With empty chat history and after previous conversations
The Questions We Asked
We selected questions across different categories:
- Factual: “What is the capital of Australia?”
- Creative: “Write a short poem about the ocean”
- Problem-solving: “How can I remove a coffee stain from a white shirt?”
- Opinion-based: “What’s the best way to learn Spanish?”
- Technical: “Explain how cryptocurrencies work”
What We Found
Factual questions showed the most consistency. All responses correctly identified Canberra as Australia’s capital, but GPT-4 gave more details about when it became the capital and its location.
Creative tasks showed the greatest variation. No two ocean poems were alike – different structures, imagery, and tones appeared across users.
Problem-solving questions had consistent core advice but different details. All responses mentioned cold water and dish soap for coffee stains, but in different orders and with varying additional tips.
Opinion questions revealed structural patterns with different specifics. Most responses to the Spanish learning question suggested a mix of apps, immersion, and practice – but prioritized them differently.
Technical explanations had consistent key points but varying depth. All cryptocurrency explanations mentioned blockchain, decentralization, and mining – but GPT-4 provided more nuanced details and analogies.
Key Patterns We Noticed
- GPT-4 gave longer, more detailed responses than GPT-3.5
- Responses at peak usage times (midday US hours) were slightly shorter
- Previous conversation context had the biggest impact on answer variation
- Even identical questions often got responses with different structures and examples
When Consistency Matters
Not all use cases require the same level of consistency from AI. Here’s where predictable outputs matter most:
Critical Business Applications
Businesses using ChatGPT for customer service need consistent responses to similar questions. Imagine one customer getting correct return policy information while another gets outdated details – this creates serious problems.
Banks, healthcare providers, and legal services face even higher stakes. They need AI that provides uniform, accurate information every time.
Education and Training
Teachers using AI as a learning tool need consistent explanations of concepts. Students should get a similar quality of help regardless of when they ask.
Standardized exam prep and grading also demand consistency. If the AI gives different levels of help to different students, it creates unfair advantages.
Content Creation Pipelines
Marketing teams using AI to draft materials need predictable outputs that match brand guidelines. When multiple team members use AI for related projects, wildly different AI styles create extra editing work.
Multi-Step Workflows
When AI output from one step becomes input for another process, consistency becomes crucial. Unpredictable variations can compound across steps, potentially breaking automated workflows.
When Variation Is Beneficial
Sometimes, different answers to the same question are exactly what you want:
Brainstorming and Creativity
Writers, designers, and marketers often benefit from seeing multiple approaches. Asking the same question several times with high temperature settings can generate diverse ideas and perspectives.
Try asking “Give me blog post ideas about remote work” five times in a row – you’ll get a much wider range of options than a single response could provide.
Learning Different Approaches
When learning a new skill or solving a complex problem, seeing different methods helps build a deeper understanding.
A programming student might benefit from seeing multiple ways to solve the same coding challenge, and a home cook might want various methods for making pasta sauce.
Avoiding AI Detection
If you’re creating multiple pieces of content with AI assistance, identical patterns make the AI’s fingerprints obvious. Natural variation helps content feel more human-written.
Personalizing User Experience
Different users have different needs, even when asking identical questions. A beginner asking about investing needs fundamentals, while an experienced investor needs advanced details.
Practical Tips for Users
Want more control over ChatGPT’s consistency? Try these strategies:
For More Consistent Responses:
- Set the temperature to 0 or 0.1 in the settings
- Use detailed, specific prompts that leave little room for interpretation
- Start fresh conversations rather than continuing long threads
- Use system prompts that request consistent formatting (when available)
- Try “few-shot” prompting – give examples of the exact format you want
What is few-shot prompting?
Few-shot prompting means giving ChatGPT examples of the response format you want before asking your actual question. Instead of hoping the AI understands what you want, you show it directly.
For example, here are examples of good product descriptions:
Example 1:
Product: Wireless Headphones
Description: Lightweight wireless headphones with 20-hour battery life. Features noise cancellation and comfortable ear cups. Perfect for commuters and travelers who need immersive sound without distractions.
Example 2:
Product: Coffee Maker
Description: Programmable coffee maker with a 12-cup capacity. Includes built-in grinder and timer function. Ideal for busy professionals who want fresh coffee ready when they wake up.
Now write a description for this product in the same style:
Product: Ergonomic Office Chair
This technique works because you’re giving the AI clear examples to follow rather than relying on it to guess your preferred style and format.
For More Varied Responses:
- Increase temperature settings (0.7-1.0)
- Use open-ended questions that invite creativity
- Try asking the same question multiple ways
- Request specifically that ChatGPT “think differently” from its previous answer
- Add “give me a perspective I might not have considered” to your prompt
Track Your Results
For important work, save prompts that produced good results. Creating a personal “prompt library” helps you replicate successful outcomes.
Some third-party tools now offer prompt management features that help track which prompts produced which results.
Combine Human and AI Work Effectively
The most reliable approach combines AI generation with human review. Use ChatGPT for initial drafts and ideas, but apply your own judgment before using its output.
For critical applications, compare answers from multiple AI runs to identify inconsistencies that need human attention.
Business Implications
The variable nature of ChatGPT responses creates both challenges and opportunities for businesses:
Quality Control Challenges
Organizations need processes to verify AI outputs before they reach customers or stakeholders. This might include:
- Human review of critical AI-generated content
- Automated checks for factual accuracy and brand compliance
- Regular testing with standard prompts to catch issues
- Clear guidelines for when AI can be used without review
Competitive Advantage
Companies that master prompt engineering and AI workflows gain an edge. The best results come not from casual questioning but from carefully designed prompts and systems.
Organizations with staff trained in effective AI prompting can get more consistent, useful results than competitors.
Future-Proofing Concerns
As AI models continue to evolve, today’s prompts might produce different results tomorrow. Businesses need to:
- Plan for regular updates to their AI prompts and workflows
- Document their AI processes rather than relying on tribal knowledge
- Develop ways to test whether AI outputs meet quality standards
- Create contingency plans for when AI responses drift from expectations
Building Trust With Transparency
Users appreciate knowing when they’re interacting with AI. Being transparent about:
- When AI is involved in communication
- The limitations of AI responses
- How human oversight is applied
This builds trust rather than eroding it when inconsistencies inevitably appear.
The Bottom Line
Does ChatGPT give the same answers to everyone? Clearly not.
Its responses vary based on model version, settings, conversation history, and exact phrasing. This variability makes it powerful for creative tasks but requires careful handling for business-critical applications.
The smartest approach treats ChatGPT as a collaborative partner rather than an oracle.
Its insights and drafts provide value, but your own judgment remains essential – especially when consistency matters.
By understanding what drives these variations, you can better harness AI’s strengths while guarding against its limitations.
Ready to Scale Your Business with Proven Growth Strategies?
Understanding AI tools like ChatGPT is just one piece of the puzzle when building a successful, scalable business.
The inconsistency of AI responses highlights a broader truth: relying on any single tool or tactic isn’t enough to drive sustainable growth.
At ScaleMath, we help ambitious companies implement proven growth frameworks that deliver predictable, scalable results. Our team specializes in creating custom growth strategies that build on your existing strengths while identifying new opportunities.
👋 Looking for input from a team that’s worked with category-leading companies – possibly like yours? We’re here and always happy to help! Use the contact widget in the bottom right-hand corner to get in touch or apply to work with us here.
We’ll review your current growth approach and share specific strategies that have worked for similar businesses in your industry – no strings attached.
FAQs
Why does ChatGPT sometimes contradict itself in the same conversation?
ChatGPT processes text in chunks and doesn’t perfectly remember everything it said earlier in long conversations. It also doesn’t “know” it made a contradiction – it’s generating text based on patterns, not consulting an internal database of facts.
Can I make ChatGPT give the exact same answer every time?
Not with 100% reliability. Setting the temperature to 0 increases consistency but doesn’t guarantee identical answers. For perfect consistency, you’d need to save and reuse specific outputs rather than regenerating them.
Do different ChatGPT versions have different consistency levels?
Yes. GPT-4 generally produces more consistent results than GPT-3.5 for factual questions. The paid versions also tend to follow instructions more precisely, which can improve consistency when your prompts are well-crafted.
Does paying for ChatGPT Plus change response consistency?
ChatGPT Plus gives access to GPT-4, which tends to be more precise and consistent for factual information. The Plus version also typically has fewer usage restrictions, allowing for more complex prompts that can improve consistency.
How do I know if ChatGPT is giving me a unique or standard answer?
There’s no easy way to tell. If you get very similar responses across multiple attempts with temperature 0, that suggests you’re getting a more “standard” answer. More varied responses likely mean fewer users have asked similar questions.
Will ChatGPT remember my preferences in future conversations?
No, not by default. Each new conversation starts fresh unless you’re using a custom GPT with specific instructions or features like memory. In that case, you’ll need to restate preferences in each new chat.
Does the time of day or usage volume affect ChatGPT’s consistency?
Our testing showed subtle differences during peak usage times, with slightly shorter responses. OpenAI might adjust models during high-demand periods, which could affect consistency.
Let's build better together.
